U.S. diversity push for lawyers, agents to tackle housing crisis

by Carey L. Biron | @clbtea | Thomson Reuters
Tuesday, 14 December 2021 10:20 GMT

Activists and others celebrate the purchase of a home at foreclosure auction by a community land trust in April 2021 in Berkeley, California. Handout photo by Mwende Hinojosa/Sustainable Economies Law Center.

Image Caption and Rights Information

Amid an affordability crisis and with the homeownership gap between white and Black Americans at its widest in 50 years, new programs are working to broaden the pool of people who work in the housing sector

By Carey L. Biron

WASHINGTON, Dec 14 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - Former non-profit worker Christine Hernandez had never considered becoming a housing attorney, but after 2015, when she got priced out of her home in Oakland, California, she thought a lot about the issue.

Over the next five years, Hernandez and her family went through a period of unstable housing, including nearly three years squatting. Then, last year, the landlord of the multi-unit house they were living in tried to push tenants out.

As Hernandez researched ways to fight back, she found the Radical Real Estate Law School, a new initiative helping people become housing lawyers by having them apprentice with practicing attorneys and eventually take the bar exam, bypassing traditional, expensive law programs.

Started by the nonprofit Sustainable Economies Law Center (SELC) last year, the initiative aims to create lawyers versed in nontraditional tools such as land trusts and cooperatives to help address the country's affordable housing crisis.

"I had never considered studying the law or pursuing that as a profession, but I discovered that the law is everywhere around us. You have to figure out how to navigate it," Hernandez said.

She eventually succeeded in getting the building purchased by a community land trust, a nonprofit that buys property to rent or sell at affordable prices, and then she joined the tuition-free SELC program as an apprentice.

Getting through it will take years, but Hernandez said she has already been putting her new skills to work, including helping a friend stay in her home by making use of a new California law that strengthens tenant rights.

The program's focus on broadening the pool of people who can access legal information and practice law comes as the real estate industry is taking a hard look at its own diversity - in terms of professional background, income level, race and more.

The U.S. housing industry "is perpetuating inequalities", with the highly professionalized sector keeping out many people who have direct experience of housing instability, said Chris Tittle, SELC director of land and housing justice.

The United States currently has a shortage of about 6.8 million affordable rental units, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition.

Helping families find and keep homes they can afford to live in "relies on being able to navigate and access the legal system to enforce what rights tenants often have," said Tittle, who got his law degree through an earlier version of the SELC program.

   

GUIDES OR GATEKEEPERS

For many U.S. communities, homeownership is more out of reach today than it has been for a generation.

Less than 42% of Black Americans owned a home in 2017, compared with nearly three-quarters of white Americans - the largest such gap in a half-century, according to a study from the Urban Institute think tank published last year.

Some say the real estate industry itself can help address that inequity.

The sector is vast, comprising agents, lenders, appraisers and others who together are involved in every aspect of a housing transaction, said Bryan Greene, a vice president with the National Association of Realtors (NAR).

For those trying to buy a house, a real estate agent "can be a guide or a gatekeeper," he said.

The 1.5-million-member NAR is working to right some of the discriminatory practices the real estate industry has had a hand in for over a century, Greene said.

"Real estate in the United States historically has been linked to segregation and exclusion," he said.

"If you go back 100 years, there was a concerted effort among both the industry and the population in general to limit where people of color resided, especially in northern communities."

As examples, Greene pointed to racially restrictive covenants - clauses in title deeds that prohibited non-whites from owning certain homes - which were promoted by the real estate industry before they became illegal in 1968. 

There were also rules limiting who could get financing and discrimination around appraisals, all of which made it harder for African-Americans to buy and sell their houses in certain areas. 

Last year, the NAR issued an apology for its past policies that exacerbated racial inequality, saying they were "an outrage to our morals and our ideals."

The association has also begun training its members on how to avoid implicit bias when dealing with prospective homeowners, and Greene said progress is being made.

"We're finding that the culture is changing," he said.

"There's a lot more engagement among real estate professionals on how to shape their communities to be the diverse, inclusive places they want."

 

Legal aid advocates and others celebrate the purchase of a home at foreclosure auction by a community land trust in April 2021 in Berkeley, California. Handout photo by Mwende Hinojosa/Sustainable Economies Law Center.

FAIRER PROCESS

 Also hoping to diversify the U.S. housing sector, real estate referral company HomeLight and the National Association of Real Estate Brokers launched a program in February aimed at growing the number of Black real estate agents in the country.

Currently just 6% of all American real estate agents are Black, according to analysis based on 2019 U.S. census data.

The program's initial tranche of 10 participants - who get financial and business support to move toward licensing - are all under 35, an effort to guide Black millennials toward homeownership, said HomeLight COO Sumant Sridharan.

"By increasing Black representation within the real estate agent community, we hope this program will build trust within local communities throughout the United States and help get more Black people on the path to homeownership," he said in emailed comments.

Given the significant competition for housing across the country, the industry needs to face the potential bias in everything it does, said Dan Reed, an urban planner who is also a licensed real estate agent in Montgomery County, Maryland.

For instance, Reed pointed to the way real estate ads commonly tout which school district a house is in - but only when the school is affluent and majority white.

"That turns a public amenity - the school - into a private luxury, but it also reinforces (the belief) that these schools and neighborhoods are inherently more valuable," he said.

In his own work, Reed has also stopped having prospective buyers use personal letters and photos to try to convince sellers to accept their purchase offer, after he realized that almost every time the strategy succeeded, the buyers were white.

"This is one thing that can make the process fairer for everyone," he said.

Related stories:

OPINION: Hurricane Ida should be a wake-up call to address housing shortage

Good business or digital bias? The divisive rise of 'proptech'

Will power: Could property inheritance help close U.S. 'wealth gap'?

We want to hear from you: what critical stories and perspectives are missing from our coverage of systemic racism around the world?

Your responses to our short survey will help shape our reporting.

You can submit your response anonymously. If you provide an email address, we may follow up with you for more information. Any information you share with us will remain strictly confidential and will be used only in accordance with our Privacy Statement.

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.